Skip to main content

Maintenance, Maintenance, Maintenance

What topic do we discuss most with our clients?  Maintenance.  

Maintenance is an expense category that, on the owner statement or income/expense statements, appears as one line item but covers a wide array of repairs or improvements made by in-house maintenance or our 3rd-party vendors.  

Many clients see these line-item expenses and question what exactly they are - especially if looking at statements only once a year (Usually when getting together for tax filing time).  

Our property managers reach out for larger expenditures, typically when they approach $500; however, it is easy to forget what these are many months later.   

What exactly does maintenance cover?  Primarily, maintenance covers Tenant requests (broken toilet flush handles, clogged sinks, appliance problems, etc.), Turnovers (Making the unit “rent-ready” for the next tenant), and City correction notices (biannual inspections for the local municipality that can produce long lists of required repairs).  

  1. TENANT REQUESTS

Tenants are a diverse group with different personalities, backgrounds, and expectations.  As you can imagine, most demand safe and habitable living conditions.  As you can imagine, some are much more demanding, which can challenge landlords/property managers in satisfying these “needy” and burdensome requests.  This is a balance where the desires of the tenants don’t always match the financial realities of owning a rental property – In other words, we can't just jump on every request that is made by a tenant.  

Our guiding principle is to address most reasonable repair requests in a timely manner, prioritizing emergencies or safety concerns.  If there is reason to believe the repairs are actual damage caused by the tenant, we then charge them for these repairs.  The most common examples are foreign objects in drains that cause backups.  Other examples include holes in walls/doors/windows that we have a record of not being there at move-in.  We add the charges to the tenant’s ledger and then recover those funds for the owner.

Things do just break from use.  We manage many 100+ year homes that can have maintenance issues as things reach the end of their lives.  We do the best we can to keep things in working order, and if a tenant’s request isn’t reasonable, we have to say no or reach out for permission from the owner before moving forward. 


  1. TURNOVERS

Turnovers can be one of the most expensive “maintenance” items we perform on rental properties.  Turnovers often include painting, flooring, and general repairs like smoke detector replacement, lock changes, and all sorts of minor things that need to be done to make a unit “rent-ready”.  Tenants can leave their units/house in wonderful condition.  Many do not.  I could make a coffee table book on some of the unit conditions I’ve encountered over the years.  Luckily, those are rare.  

Tenant damage is determined after move-out and possession is received.  We do a thorough walk-through with photos and a description of everything needed to prepare for a future tenant.  We go over this list, identify what charges would be appropriate to assign to the tenant as damage (after comparing to their move-in checklist), and then do the security deposit disposition.   

Getting a property to “rent ready” (see our standards here) is more than just fixing damage.  Many times, interior painting is necessary.  It’s one of the best ways to freshen up a rental property that cleaning just can’t do.  It’s gotten more expensive over the years, so when there are many rooms, the prices go up accordingly.  We try to make the best decision about when to do this, and if we can hold off until a future date, we will.  

In between tenants is also the obvious time to install new flooring while the unit is vacant.  Flooring is another item that can be pricey.  We try to use high-traffic mid-grade carpet or mid-grade vinyl plank/sheet vinyl flooring when we can.  Some higher-end homes may need a better quality for those applications.  We take them case by case.  

For turnovers that require paint and flooring, it’s almost certain to exceed the typical $500 amount for owner approval.  We try to send estimates for turnover costs as soon as possible in order to keep the turnover process moving.


With turnover costs being one of the most expensive maintenance items performed, the best way to avoid them altogether is to MINIMIZE TURNOVER.  We can't keep people from moving out, but we can try to make their experience while living with us as pleasant as possible by being responsive, making timely repairs for their maintenance requests, and not aggressively adjusting their rent upwards year after year.   Happy tenants stay in place longer and renew- even with slight increases in rent.  


  1. CITY CORRECTION NOTICES

The other large maintenance category that can catch owners off guard many times are the required correction notices that the City of Kalamazoo or other surrounding municipalities send to comply with their rental certification program.   There are some areas that are far less aggressive than others.  Many of the portfolios we manage are withing the City of Kalamazoo whose inspection process is quite thorough and demanding of rental properties and their owners.   

These inspections cover not only safety items like fire extinguishers and smoke alarms, but anything that is in disrepair in the eyes of the inspector who will cite a code violation.  Items also include peeling paint (inside and out!), rotten wood, flooring that is worn out, gutters that need cleaning, evidence of water in a basement, non-working outlets, cracked windows, leaking water heaters etc etc.  I have even had inspectors cite a sink full of dirty dishes as “uncleanly environment".  

These inspections can be extremely subjective and vary by inspector, but when they cite something, it’s usually something that they require to be repaired.  There are times when a case can be made to defer or challenge something on a correction notice, but there must be a good case for the appeal.  We can help determine those cases.

Because of the cost that many of these lists require to stay compliant, we try to give estimates on the full list of repairs.  It is very common for these lists to easily reach 1200-2000. 


Other maintenance incorporates the items above, and then, although expended on another line item, are CAPITAL EXPENDITURES (these are depreciated).  These are things like new appliances, new flooring, new roofing, new remodels etc.  Of course these are typically approved by owners before installation. 


Maintenance, like much of the rest of our daily expenses, has increased in cost.   Some estimates put repair costs up 46% over a four-year period (rising from $1,140 per apartment in 2018 to $1,664 in 2022), and repair/maintenance expenses rose more than 28% since 2021 alone.  Total repairs and maintenance spiked 13.7% in a single recent peak year, with specific items like appliances, general repairs, and painting jumping 20% or more.  Central air-conditioning repair and maintenance costs rose 13.07% year-over-year.  House-cleaning and routine turnover services climbed 7.35% year-over-year.  Lawn-mowing and exterior upkeep increased 6.98% year-over-year.

-National Apartment Association.


Maintenance is a necessary expense all real estate investors must endure.  Stomaching these costs can be hard, and some years the pain can be difficult.  Long-term investors tend to realize they are necessary, temporary (hopefully), and can improve (or keep) the value of the asset.  Some years will be better than others due to maintenance costs alone.  Keep the faith – communication on these matters between the property manager and the owner should prove effective for the long-term goals of your investment.  

back